Charcoal Vs Clay Mask: Can I Use Them Both? What’s Better?

Charcoal Vs Clay Mask: Can I Use Them Both? What’s Better? Let’s compare them!

In today’s article, we are reviewing Charcoal Vs clay masks; I’m also sharing some individual information about both treatments.

Charcoal Masks: Are They Better?

Charcoal masks remove impurities, control excess oil, minimize pores, and remove pollutants, toxins, and makeup residuals.

They are slightly exfoliating, and as a result, your skin should become glowy, soft, and smooth. 

This mask is great for all skin types, especially oily and acne-prone skin, as it potentializes cleansing and removes inflammatory toxins.

Charcoal Vs Clay Mask

It is all good, but there are some contra-indications to using charcoal masks.

You should not use charcoal masks if you have a skin allergy, rosacea, or hypersensitive and dehydrated skin. 

Can I Mix It With Other Products?

You can mix charcoal masks with moisturizers, soaps, and other skin masks.

 A good suggestion is to mix it with colloidal oatmeal to hydrate and control oleosity.

What Is The Best Way To Use It?

The easiest and safest way to use charcoal masks is to buy masks and products that contain them instead of trying DIY recipes.

Learn More: 

Clay Masks: Are They Better?

Clay Masks: Are They Better?

Clay masks are naturally composed of silicate microparticles, trace elements, and some metals, such as Magnesium, Aluminum, Calcium, Potassium, Manganese, Sodium, and Iron.

  • Aluminum: acts against lack of tonicity and has healing action.
  • Iron: is important in cellular respiration. The lack of iron in the skin results in thin, dry, and inelastic skin.
  • Magnesium: helps in hydration and collagen fiber synthesis.
  • Manganese: action in collagen biosynthesis, anti-infectious, healing, and anti-allergic.
  • Silicon: provides hydration, acts against skin sagging, and reduces inflammation.
  • Sodium and Potassium help maintain hydration and the ionic balance of skin cells.

It works better for all skin types but is less drying than charcoal masks.

However, they are mostly indicated for oily and combination skin.

If you have dry skin, make sure that your skin is not extremely dry.

Sensitive skin will also benefit from clay masks, as some of them are very gentle, anti-bactericidal, and nourishing.

You can find many different clay masks with different compositions, colors, and functions.

Some Types Of Clay Masks Examples

The white clay is great for skin spots, and you can use it to treat melasma.

Apart from that, white clay removes skin oleosity, evens skin tone, and nourishes.

The red clay mask renews the skin cells, which are anti-aging, nourishing, smoothing, and great for sensitive and acne-prone skin.

The green clay mask is great for oily skin, is astringent, toning, bactericidal, analgesic, and pore clearer.

Pink clay masks are antiseptic and healing, great for sensitive skin.

Its anti-inflammatory effect is great for treating cellulitis and sagging skin.

There are many clay masks for different skin concerns; you can learn all about them in this clay mask guide

Learn More: 

Can I Mix With Other Products?

Yes, you can mix clay masks with some essential oils and other products. 

You can also apply different clay masks to different face areas to target multiple concerns.

For example, you can use a pink mask on the T-zone while using a green mask in the other areas.

What Is The Best Way To Use It?

You can buy the clay powder and mix it with water, following the fabricant’s recommendations.

It is also possible to buy many different cosmetics that contain clay in the composition.

ProsCons
Sebum ControlDries the skin out
antibacterial actionCan be irritating
improves acneAbrasive
Purifying action

Charcoal Vs Clay Masks: Which One Is Better?

Charcoal Vs Clay Mask

They both are great natural masks that are purifying, providing a deeper cleanser.

They are great for oil control and skin protection and provide smooth radiating skin.

In the end, it will depend on your skin type and the concern you want to treat.

Generally speaking, clay masks are less drying than charcoal masks, so if you tend to dry skin, it is better to opt for clay masks.

However, if you have extremely dry skin, it is better to consult a dermatologist before using any of these masks.

If you have sensitive skin, it is better to use one of the clay masks that are nourishing, such as the pink and white clay masks.

You can use both clay and charcoal masks for oily skin with excellent results.

If your skin is extremely oily, you should definitely adopt the charcoal mask to your skincare routine.

Can You Use Them Both?

Frequently you don’t have to choose between the two, as you can use them both without problems.

If you have an extremely oily T-zone, you can apply a charcoal mask there and then the clay mask in other areas.

Some products combine clay masks and charcoal masks.

Charcoal Vs Clay Masks: How To Apply?

Remember that charcoal and clay masks are not indicated for everyday usage.

Using these masks once or twice a week will be enough to treat your skin.

If your skin is extremely oily, it is ok to do it twice a week, but try it out before because you may not even need to use it more than once.

Charcoal Mask

You can buy activated charcoal and make your own mask or you can buy industrialized charcoal masks which are ready to use.

Clay mask

  • In a bowl, place 1 tablespoon of clay and add a tablespoon of mineral water or saline solution.
  • Mix the liquid well and add more until you get a paste (if it gets too liquid, add more clay).
  • Then, with the aid of a spatula or wide makeup brush. Cover your face with the mixture.
  • Once it starts to dry, remove it completely with plenty of water.

How to Choose Charcoal or Clay Masks?

First, have in mind your skin type and the concern you want to treat.

If your skin is more sensitive and, or, on the drier side, opt for clay masks.

If you have combination and oily skin, you can opt for a charcoal mask.

Oily skin will benefit from both masks

What To Look For?

  • Clay masks: take a look at the type of clay mask. The colors of the mineral vary according to their composition and the benefits they provide to the skin 
  • Before purchasing any product with activated carbon, it is best to read the composition. Note that no ingredients are likely to cause allergies.

Ingredients

Natural ingredients such as tea tree have an astringent action, while copaiba oil complements the action of green clay.

On the other hand, ruby ​​powder stimulates collagen production and blends well with red clay.

On the other hand, Mineral Charcoal provides deep cleaning and is usually combined with black clay.

However, you should be careful with synthetic ingredients as they can harm your skin.

This is the case for parabens, preservatives, dyes, and mineral oils.

The ideal is to choose products that do not contain these substances in their composition.

Why Use Face Masks?

Facial masks have concentrated formulas that improve skin texture, bringing benefits such as hydration, anti-aging action, detox, increased luminosity, and even making pores less apparent. 

They have a higher concentration of actives than other cosmetic options and should be used once or twice a week. 

Similar To Charcoal Vs Clay Mask

Charcoal Vs Clay Mask: Can I Use Them Both? What’s Better?